Showing posts with label China. Show all posts
Showing posts with label China. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 10, 2009

Tibetan double-take

Fifty years ago today, a massive uprising against Chinese rule in Tibet ended with thousands of Tibetans dead, thousands more forcibly resettled and Tibet's spiritual and political leader indefinitely exiled, kicking off half a century (and counting) of quasi-cultural genocide as Beijing paid Han Chinese to move to the troubled region.

Or, fifty years ago today, millions of Tibetan serfs were liberated from tyrannical, theocratic and backwards rule and shown all the wonders of a Communist Chinese society about to plunge headlong into the Cultural Revolution, kicking off half a century of modernization and economic growth.

Take your pick.

I cannot think of a single China-related issue where the gap in conceptions of reality is so friggin' enormous. A quick glance at Chinese coverage and international coverage of today's event in Dharmasala proves as much.

In the eyes of Beijing and most Chinese citizens, Tibet is an inalienable part of China, the Dalai Lama is a troublemaker and the "Free Tibet" movement an example of the rest of the world trying to gang up on China under a Eurocentric interpretation of human rights. Most Chinese people I've spoken with are genuinely at a loss as to why China is seen in such a bad light when it comes to Tibet.

A conversation with a politics professor at Fudan University threw some of these gaps into sharp relief.

He Junzhi in the U.K. during last March's protests--when peaceful protests were met with a massive police crackdown and then turned into violent attacks on Han businesses.

"Most media are very against the Chinese central government and criticised the Communist Party's policy. But a very strange situation is that a lot of the criticism didn't know ... what Tibet is," he said. "Last year, some [Chinese] people were wondering, 'We have given you so much--why did you do this against us? Some people are very puzzled."

He said this criticism of China could only stem from the Dalai Lama's ability to manipulate people who look up to him as a spiritual leader--blinding them, He argued, to other facts.

"The Dalai Lama is very good at the media language. He often uses language the media want to hear--for example, 'human rights', 'autonomy,' 'self-government.'"

Now, He insisted, Tibetans better off than they were 50 years ago and the Chinese government has realized Tibetans care about spiritual aspects of their lives, rather than just material ones. But at the same time, He said Beijing needs to wean Tibetans off their reliance on religion--"the process of modernization is a separation of church and state," he argued.

Now, he said, Beijing has better policies in place to "calm down the Tibetan people" and ensure last year's protests don't repeat themselves.

This yawning chasm between what Beijing sees and what the rest of the world sees never ceases to freak me out.

On the one hand, if "Free Tibet" continues to be a rallying call that demonizes an entire country in the eyes of people who know little to nothing about China or Tibet, China's going to remain on the defensive in an attempt to save face and the Chinese population will be united behind its government against what it sees as a hostile, Sinophobic international community.

On the other hand, Beijing holds a lot more cards in this situation. Freeing up Internet and SMS access in Tibet and allowing foreign journalists in would be a good start; it's hard to convince people you have nothing to hide when you put all your efforts into, well, hiding things.

If the Chinese government continues to dismiss Tibetans' calls for cultural, religious and political autonomy as backwards and something to be answered with renewed efforts to convince Tibetans of how much better off they are now than they were 50 years ago--while avoiding at all costs any serious discussions with the Dalai Lama, hoping he'll just go away--it's unlikely the "Xizang xiqing" will be resolved in the next half-century, either.

Thursday, March 5, 2009

Stimulate this

To the thrill and excitement of all, the National People's Congress began its annual pooh-bah Parliamentary get-together this week.

Of course, this year's conference is more than a CCP rubber-stamping love-in: The jinrong weiji has ensured the world was watching to see what Hu, Wen & Co. have to offer, hoping whatever life raft they offer China will be big and bouyant enough for the rest of the global economy to hang on for dear life.

Or, you know, whatever.

To be honest, I don't know nearly enough about economics to make an educated assessment of the mechanics of China's economic outlook. Then again, there isn't really much to go on, given Wen Jiabao's speil:
“The external economic environment has become more serious, and uncertainties have increased significantly. ... Continuous drop in economic growth rate due to the impact of the global financial crisis has become a major problem affecting the overall situation. This has resulted in excess production capacity in some industries, caused some enterprises to experience operating difficulties and exerted severe pressure on employment”
OK, so that isn't a newsflash for anyone, nor is his declaration that the government will do its best to keep people employed, diversity export markets and somehow convince consumers to buy stuff.

It isn't surprising that China's trying to gloss over any suggestion its economy is tanking with the same craptacular spluttering as the rest of the world; nor is it a shock that Wen's reassurances are short on details and long on platitudes. This is how the NCP rolls, promises of transparency be damned.

What is clear, however, is that there won't be any more mammon manna from heaven--at least not from Beijing's pocketbook. Despite hints last week the previous stimulus package could as much as double in size (that'd make a honkin 8 trillion yuan, if you're counting), it looks like the economy is going to have to cope with a measly 4 trillion--most of it dedicated to infrastructure and the like, and much of it coming from local governments and private sources (as opposed to the central government responsible for all these cash-rich promises).

Will this be enough to keep China's economy steaming along at a pace to satisfy anxious consumers, panicky unemployed migrants and the freaked-out and freakily volatile financial markets?

Maybe. But I'm going to guess no.

Tuesday, March 3, 2009

For your next family vacation: A visit to the Sichuan Earthquake Theme Park (tm)


Yep, nothing like turning a national disaster into a tourist opportunity.

Beichuan county, one of the areas worst devastated by the 8.0 earthquake that ripped through Sichuan last May, is being transformed into a "world class" relic site, where the ruins of buildings reduced to rubble that crushed thousands of people in a massive quake will be preserved for visitors.

The projects, which come with a total price tag of more than 50 billion yuan, will preserve ethnic cultural sites and turn Mianyang county into "a first class travel destination that combines sightseeing, meeting, leisure, and holiday facilities."

Ooh la la.

And the sites are already attracting the curious: About 200,000 tourists visited Beichuan during Spring Festival in January, and planners hope their endeavour will bring in enough cash to cover both the cost of the 93 individual restoration projects and the 6 billion yuan Mianyang lost in tourist revenue thanks to quake-related damages (not to mention sightseers leery of travelling a region that has been rocked by twice-monthly mini-quakes since May).



In the meantime, the millions of people left homeless in the earhquake's aftermath are still homeless, and they're wondering where the billions of yuan in earthquake relief donations have gone.

At least some of that money has allegedly been spent on snazzy cars for local bureaucrats; although few people here would ever go so far as casting aspersions on the conduct of the central government, many refer to corruption and misspending by local officials.

Beijing isn't about to let that derail what has so far been a pretty stellar publicity campaign, however. The government has given in-person notice to frustrated quake survivors that if they complain or talk to the press, their asses are grass and they can kiss goodbye any chance at getting help rebuilding homes destroyed in May (as it is, the gov is paying less than a third of the total cost of the homes--the rest will come from savings, or from cash used to pay off families of kids crushed in the rubble of shoddily built schools).

Cries of foul continue, however; a riot erupted in the Mianyang village of Baolin last month as thousands of villagers stormed a police station over disagreements on how the local aid fund was being spent. One person was killed and 10 injured during the fracas. (apologies for the Epoch link; only other English-language article I could find was the SCMP and that's behind a paywall). Residents of the ruined towns now being turned into museums are being relocated to new cities--"New Beichuan," etc--a ways away. Not everyone is delighted at the prospect of

But most of all, residents are just confused and frustrated. Families I spoke with in Shifang earlier this year are struggling to figure out how to build the homes that are still incomplete almost a year after the quake; they also can't figure out where all the billions of yuan in aid money is going to. In a country where people live for--and through--their kids, having lost their only children leaves these families little hope for what looks like a fairly bleak future.

In January, these families were living in tarp-and-bamboo tents permeated by moisture in rural Sichuan's damp climate. If they're lucky, they'll scrape together the money to build real houses, and maybe reconstruct livelihoods interrupted or made impossible by the quake's devastation. If they're really lucky, these now-childless parents will have more kids--maybe they'll even be able to afford medical costs needed for risky 40-something pregnancies in an area with few good hospitals.

And if they're hyperbolically fortunate, perhaps--just perhaps--someday they'll be able to take their kids to the Mianyang Earthquake Memorial Theme Park (TM).


Sunday, March 1, 2009

Animal head update

Joke's on Christie's.

The Chinese man identified as the winning bidder says he can't pay the 15.7 million euros he bid over the phone.

Cai Mingchao, director of the Xiamen Harmony Art International Auction Company (try saying that eight times fast), described the bid as a "patriotic act."

"I think any Chinese person would have stood up at that moment. ... I was merely fulfilling my responsibilities."

Naturally, it's like a harmonious society come early for people in China who were furious over the sculptures' sale to begin with. Commenters have lit up the blogosphere, gleefully discussing the egg they see on Christie's face.

I still think those heads are ugly.

Wednesday, February 25, 2009

Even Canada thinks Canada's China policies suck: Xinhua

I can almost guarantee Chinese state media care way more about this than anyone in Ottawa.

Which, I guess, is kind of the point.

Sunday, February 22, 2009

Hey, big spender

It ain't for nothing the Chinese term for "financial crisis" (金融危机; jinrong weiji) contains the word ji 机--opportunity.

As corporate titans around the world scramble for cash to avoid going belly up, China is becoming an unlikely sugar daddy.

As the Christian Science Monitor reports, Chinese companies are on an "international spending spree," buying up stakes in everything from U.S. auto manufacturers to Canadian oil firms to Australian mining companies.

Massive loans to Russia and Brazil--to the tune of $25 billion and $10 billion, respectively--has China swimming in oil.

It seems odd: Local exporters, especially smaller factories, are struggling to stay afloat as foreign demand dives. But both state-owned enterprises, surprisingly flush for cash and with the government's directive to secure massive amounts of commodities and natural resources, and opportunistic private companies are getting in on the game.

It's an exciting time for a country unused to acquiring foreign assets--a bit of a coming-out party for Chinese titans and a welcome reversal of that "century of humiliation" when European and American commercial interests plundered the Middle Kingdom for all it was worth.

Needless to say, becoming everyone's favourite bailout provider (well, maybe after the U.S. Fed. But whatever) has its pitfalls: Australia has yet to approve the Rio Tinto/Chinalco deal and some fear foreign ownership of national industries, especially given the involvement of government and government-backed companies in these high-rolling deals. And China has its own troubled manufacturing sector and ballooning unemployment rate to worry about.

But for now, Chinese firms seem happy to troll the globe's bargain basements. And I doubt the companies on the receiving end of the cash are going to complain.



Saturday, February 21, 2009

"We will get along very well"

She came. She saw. She schmoozed it up with some Chinese dignitaries.

Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton seems to have hit all the right notes during her whirlwind trip to the Middle Kingdom.

She emphasized China's vital role in helping the global economy back onto its feet, while aggressively downplaying any suggestions of protectionism brought on by the watered-down-to-the-point-of-irrelevance "Buy American" clause in the latest stimulus package. Her suggestion that Americans and Chinese could trade financial traits, with the former saving more and the latter spending more, would be funny if it weren't kind of sad.

She urged the Chinese government to take a leading role in combating climate change, tackling head-on the claim that China's just industrializing the same way the U.S. and Europe did way back on the late 19th century--in an extremely unsustainable manner.

“When we were industrializing and growing, we didn’t know any better; neither did Europe,” she said during a visit to a geothermal power plant. “Now we’re smart enough to figure out how to have the right kind of growth.”

Well, uh, I might debate that last point. But whatever; I'm sure the people giving Hillary her tour were just glad she wasn't touring nearby Tianjin's factories, or testing Beijing's air quality.

China has been under a lot of pressure to clean up its environmental act, and despite continuing protestations that the rest of the world is just a big bully and should pay attention to its own dirty power and overflowing landfills, the government until recently had been doing a lot to highlight its any and all attempts to "green" construction, manufacturing and transportation. Of course that all has changed thanks to the jinrong weiji, which took environmental concerns off the table to replace them with the overarching, panicked imperative to keep the economy churning at as fast a pace as possible.

Although stimulus plans in Canada and the U.S. have made environmental initiatives a priority, China's government has focused on infrastructure, lending and gettings its population to buy something--anything. Less reusing and recycling, more consumption, dammit!

But anyway.

More significant is what wasn't mentioned during Clinton's visit--namely, human rights concerns. A hypersensitive issue in China at the best of times, the minggan factor grew exponentially given the timing--months before the 20th anniversary of the infamous Tian'anmen Square massacre and a few short weeks before the 50th anniversary of a massive uprising in Tibet.

Recently, China underwent its first UN Human Rights Council review. It was awkward.

China got kudos for its success in reducing poverty, and breathless requests for advice from the Philippines, Algeria, Vietnam and Malaysia as to how they could do the same.

But Zhongguo's dignitaries were unimpressed by persnickety questions from the Canuck and Aussie camps: What about those alleged arbitrary detentions of Tibetans, Uyghurs, Mongols and Falun Gong? When is China going to publish a list of annual executions and set up an independent human rights institution?

Requests like these "did not enjoy the support of China."

Oh, snap.

The U.S. didn't say much then, and its emissary didn't say much this weekend.

Phew.




Clip courtesy of AP and China TV. Not YouTube because mYouTube here is a stinking pile of melamine.